I Broke a Safety Rule. Can I Still Collect Benefits?

Pennsylvania employees may still be able to collect workers’ compensation benefits even if they break a safety rule at work. The workers’ compensation system is no-fault, meaning that, in most cases, injured employees may collect benefits no matter who was to blame for the accident. In exchange for providing workers’ compensation insurance regardless of fault, employers are protected from personal injury lawsuits for their employees’ work injuries. However, depending on each state’s laws regarding employee conduct, there may be exceptions to this general rule.

Pennsylvania Employees May Still Be Eligible for Benefits

Generally, workers are eligible for workers’ compensation benefits even if their accident was caused by their own negligence or carelessness. However, workers’ compensation insurance companies will often look for ways to deny benefits and may initially deny a worker’s claim. Insurers may deny benefits because they dispute whether the injury happened at work, they suspect fraud, or they claim another defense, including:

  • Willful misconduct – When an employee intentionally disregards an employer’s rules or interests, the insurance company may use the willful misconduct defense. An injured employee may be denied coverage if he or she purposely violated a known and enforced safety rule.
  • Horseplay – Workers who are injured as a result of engaging in horseplay at work may be denied benefits. To avoid paying benefits, employers must show that the injury was caused by the employee’s violation of a workplace rule, that the employee knew about the rule, and that the horseplay was disconnected from the employee’s duties.
  • Intentional self-infliction of injuries – If an employee intentionally injures him or herself, the employer is not required to provide benefits. However, the employer does bear the burden of proving that the employee intentionally engaged in high-risk behavior, which caused his or her injury.
  • Intoxication/illegal drug use – Workers who are injured while intoxicated or under the influence of illegal drugs may be ineligible for workers’ compensation. However, benefits may be granted if it is determined that the injury would have happened whether the employee was intoxicated/under the influence or not.

Injured Workers Are Not Automatically Excluded from Coverage Due to Safety Rule Violations

Whether an injured worker may collect workers’ compensation benefits even though they violated a workplace safety rule depends on the specific facts of the case. Generally, employees are still entitled to benefits even if they violate a safety rule because the workers’ compensation system in Pennsylvania is no-fault.

However, insurance companies may deny coverage by claiming several defenses, including willful misconduct, horseplay, intentional self-infliction of injuries, or intoxication/illegal drug use. Employees should therefore seek advice from a qualified attorney in their local area who can evaluate their case and explain all their legal options.

Philadelphia Workers’ Compensation Lawyers at Larry Pitt & Associates, P.C. Help Injured Employees Get the Benefits to Which They Are Entitled

If you were injured in at work, you may be entitled to benefits regardless of whether you broke a safety rule. Contact a skilled Philadelphia workers’ compensation lawyer at Larry Pitt & Associates, P.C. for a free consultation. Our experienced attorneys proudly serve all types of workers in Philadelphia and throughout the state. To arrange a free consultation to discuss your case, please complete our online contact form or call us at 888-PITT-LAW today.

We proudly represent injured workers across Pennsylvania, including those in Abington, Ambler, Ardmore, Bala Cynwyd, Bensalem, Clifton Heights, Crum Lynne, Darby, Downingtown, Doylestown, Drexel Hill, Essington, Folcroft, Glenolden, Haverford, Havertown, Holmes, Kutztown, Lansdowne, Media, Merion Station, Morton, Narberth, Norristown, Norwood, Philadelphia, Prospect Park, Quakertown, Reading, Roxborough, Sharon Hill, Upper Darby, West Chester, and Wynnewood.



Larry Pitt

Larry Pitt

If you've been injured, Larry Pitt & Associates can provide you with the legal assistance and representation you need to ensure that justice is served. Get in touch today for a free consultation to discuss your case. Whether it’s a work injury, auto accident, medical malpractice, or any other injury-related matter, we are here to help make sure your rights and interests are respected. We understand the stress and frustration that can accompany an injury, and we are committed to providing thorough legal guidance and support throughout the entire process.